Phil Toop

Phil Toop

Co-Founder
Managing Director
Principal Wealth Partner

Introduction 

In the world of investing, two terms often get misunderstood or conflated: the risk of losing capital and price volatility. While both are key considerations in any investment strategy, they represent very different concepts. The risk of losing capital refers to the permanent loss of your initial investment, whereas price volatility represents temporary fluctuations in an asset’s value. As your financial adviser, I want to break these ideas down, using examples and insights from behavioural finance and academic research, to empower you to make better-informed decisions about your investments.  

Risk of Losing Capital 

The risk of losing capital refers to the possibility of a permanent loss of your initial investment. This could occur if an asset depreciates significantly and does not recover, or if the company or entity behind the investment goes bankrupt. This risk is most pronounced in speculative assets or poorly diversified portfolios. 

Example 

During the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) of 2008, many investors with concentrated holdings in single stocks or non-diversified portfolios experienced significant capital loss. For example, several Australian investors saw their investments in financial institutions lose over half their value. While some stocks recovered over time, others never did, leaving investors with substantial permanent losses. 

Unlike price volatility, which may cause temporary stress but often resolves over time, the risk of losing capital is irreversible without reinvestment or corrective actions.  

Price Volatility 

Price volatility, in contrast, represents the day-to-day or short-term fluctuations in the value of an asset. Volatility is a natural characteristic of market behaviour and does not necessarily equate to a permanent loss of capital. Instead, it reflects how the market reacts to news, events, or shifts in investor sentiment. 

Volatility itself can also be a source of confusion because there are two types of volatility. Realised (or historical) volatility is a mathematical calculation based upon the actual price movements of the instrument being measured (such as a company share price, or an index level). The other type of volatility is implied volatility, which as the name suggests, is the volatility that is implied from the options market for the underlying instrument. This implied volatility is the one most often referred to when discussions around volatility come up and there are indices which track this implied volatility of share market indexes. In Australia it is called the S&P/ASX 200 VIX Index, an index that goes back to 2008.  This is sometimes referred to as the fear index, as it captures the nervousness of the market in times of uncertainty.  

Example 

At the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, the ASX 200 index dropped nearly 40% between February and March. However, by the end of the year, it had largely recovered to pre-pandemic levels. This volatility caused stress for many investors, but those who stayed invested and maintained a diversified portfolio avoided permanent loss and benefited from the recovery. 

The chart below shows the S&P/ASX 200 index (blue line) and the S&P/ASX 200 VIX index (red line) in the period 2 January to 31 December 2020. (The S&P/ASX 200 is used as a representation of the whole Australian share market). You can see that the index was climbing in the first seven weeks of 2020, and implied volatility was low. Then Covid-19 struck and the index fell and volatility rose (very sharply) indicating the fear and uncertainty that the market (and the world) was facing. Then by the fourth week of March, the market started to recover at the same time as implied volatility fell. So, whilst the VIX index rose (telling us that volatility was high), it didn’t have any predictive power (it rose in reaction to the market falling) and of itself, the high volatility didn’t need to translate into investor losing money (unless they sold when the market was down).  

Chart of S&P/ASX 200 index and the S&P/ASX 200 VIX index

This illustrates the importance of aligning investments with your investment time horizon, and the value of having an adviser to guide you through these fearful times. Someone who had to sell in March 2020 due to a planned expense may have lost money. Someone who had their superannuation invested in market type investments and with 10 years until retirement didn’t have to sell and is now likely to be well ahead on their investments.  

In contrast to the permanent nature of capital loss, price volatility is part of market cycles. It often corrects itself with time, rewarding investors who maintain a disciplined, long-term approach.  

Key Differences 

To further clarify, here’s a direct comparison: 

Aspect  Risk of Losing Capital  Price Volatility 
Definition  Permanent loss of investment  Temporary fluctuations in asset value 
Cause  Insolvency, poor diversification  Market reactions, investor sentiment 
Impact  Cannot recover without reinvestment  Typically recovers with time 
Example  Company bankruptcy during the GFC  ASX 200’s sharp fall and recovery in 2020 

Think of price volatility as turbulence on a flight—uncomfortable but temporary. In contrast, the risk of losing capital is like the plane never reaching its destination.  

Insights from Behavioural Finance 

The principles of behavioural finance provide valuable insights into how investors perceive and respond to risk and volatility. 

Loss Aversion 

Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky identified that people often fear losses more than they value equivalent gains—a phenomenon known as loss aversion. This can cause investors to overreact to short-term volatility, mistaking it for the risk of losing capital, and make poor decisions like selling investments at the wrong time. 

Long-Term Perspective 

Nobel laureate Robert Shiller demonstrated that while markets are volatile in the short term, their performance tends to stabilise over the long run. Investors who adopt a long-term view and stick with diversified portfolios are better positioned to avoid permanent capital loss and achieve their financial goals.  

How to Mitigate Risk and Manage Volatility 

Here are three strategies to help you navigate these risks and make informed decisions: 

  1. Diversification

Diversification is the cornerstone of reducing the risk of losing capital. By spreading your investments across a range of asset classes, sectors, and geographies, you minimise the impact of poor performance from any single investment. 

  1. Know Your Risk Tolerance

Understanding your risk tolerance—how much uncertainty you’re comfortable with—helps in creating a portfolio that aligns with your financial goals and emotional comfort. Tools like risk profiling questionnaires can provide insights into your preferences. 

  1. Stay Invested

History has shown that market recoveries often follow periods of high volatility. For example, data from the ASX illustrates that staying invested through market downturns can lead to long-term growth. Reacting emotionally to short-term price swings can lock in losses and hinder future gains.  

Data-Driven Insights 

Historical market performance supports these principles: 

ASX 200 Growth (2000-2024): Despite multiple periods of volatility, the ASX 200 grew from around 3,000 points in 2000 to over 8,400 points by late 2024, demonstrating the resilience and long-term growth potential of the market.  

Conclusion 

Understanding the difference between the risk of losing capital and price volatility is essential for making sound investment decisions. While the risk of losing capital represents a permanent setback, price volatility is often temporary and part of the natural ebb and flow of markets. 

By leveraging diversification, assessing your risk tolerance, and maintaining a long-term perspective, you can navigate market uncertainties with confidence. As your adviser, I’m here to guide you through these challenges and help build a robust investment portfolio tailored to your goals. 

If you’d like to discuss your investments or have questions about your risk tolerance and portfolio strategy, please don’t hesitate to reach out. Together, we can ensure your investments are aligned with your financial aspirations and risk comfort.

Important Note: The information provided on this post is of a general nature and does not take into account your personal financial situation, objectives, or needs. Before acting on any information, consider its appropriateness and seek advice from a licensed financial adviser. Dorset Wealth Management is authorised to provide financial services under Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) No. 558504. For more information, refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) or contact us directly.