Phil Toop

Phil Toop

Co-Founder
Managing Director
Principal Wealth Partner

Introduction

The private assets industry has experienced explosive growth over the past decade, with institutional investors allocating unprecedented amounts of capital to private equity, private debt, and other alternative investments. Yet beneath the glossy marketing materials and impressive return statistics lies a complex web of misconceptions, measurement problems, and potential wealth transfers that sophisticated investors must understand to navigate this landscape effectively.

The Great Volatility Illusion

At the heart of private asset investing lies one of finance's most persistent and dangerous misconceptions: the confusion between risk and volatility. This fundamental misunderstanding has led to a widespread belief that private assets offer superior risk-adjusted returns simply because they appear less volatile than publicly traded securities.

Understanding the Fundamental Distinction

Risk and volatility are not synonymous, though they're often treated as such in investment analysis. Risk refers to the possibility of permanent capital loss – the chance that an investment will not recover its value and will fundamentally impact your final financial outcome. Volatility, by contrast, measures short-term price fluctuations – how much and how rapidly an investment's value changes over time.

The key distinction lies in timing and permanence. Risk can involve both short-term and long-term issues with potential for permanent losses, while volatility tends to focus on short-term fluctuations that aren't necessarily permanent. A volatile asset might decline substantially one day but recover the next, whereas risk-related issues like credit problems could mean the asset never recovers.

The Smoothing Effect: How Private Assets Mask True Volatility

The misconception about private assets stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of how they are valued. Private assets aren't less volatile – they're just less transparently priced. This creates what industry experts call "smoothed returns" that mask the true underlying volatility.

Unlike public markets where prices are determined by continuous trading, private assets are typically valued quarterly or even annually using subjective methodologies. This infrequent marking creates an artificial smoothness in reported returns that bears little resemblance to the actual economic volatility these assets experience.

When investment managers calculate risk-adjusted returns using metrics like the Sharpe ratio, they typically use reported volatility as the risk measure. For private assets, this reported volatility is artificially low due to the smoothing effect of infrequent valuations.

Research demonstrates this illusion dramatically. When analysts "unsmooth" private asset returns to reflect their true economic volatility, the supposed diversification benefits largely disappear. Studies have found that when reported volatilities are replaced with unsmoothed estimates, the diversification benefits of private assets are significantly reduced due to the higher volatilities and equity correlations that unsmoothing reveals.

The Persistence of This Dangerous Misconception

Several factors contribute to the persistence of this misconception:

Behavioural Biases: The smoothed returns create a psychological comfort that appeals to investors who conflate visible volatility with actual risk. The artificial calm of quarterly valuations provides false confidence that masks genuine uncertainty.

Marketing Incentives: Fund managers have strong incentives to promote the illusion of superior risk-adjusted returns. Industry presentations frequently cite the "low volatility" and "diversification benefits" of private assets as key selling points, without acknowledging the measurement artifacts behind these claims.

Measurement Challenges: The complexity of properly adjusting for smoothing effects means many institutional investors and their consultants rely on reported metrics that systematically overstate the risk-adjusted performance of private assets.

The Genuine Benefits of Private Equity Investment

Having established that the perceived lower volatility of private assets is largely illusory, it's crucial to recognise that private equity does offer several genuine and substantial benefits that justify its place in sophisticated investment portfolios. These advantages stem from fundamental differences in ownership structure and investment approach compared to public markets.

Long-Term Strategic Focus: Freedom from Quarterly Pressure

The most significant benefit of private equity ownership is the freedom from quarterly earnings pressure. Private equity ownership allows management teams to focus on long-term value creation without the constant scrutiny and short-term expectations of public markets.

The longer hold period allows company management to focus on strategy and operational improvements without the cyclical distraction of preparing for business resales every few years. In traditional private equity, strategic decisions that drive longer-term value are often postponed if an exit is anticipated within 12-24 months, but with long-term private capital, businesses can focus on delivering strategic multi-year, value-enhancing activities.

This patient capital approach enables companies to pursue bold, transformational initiatives that might be difficult to justify to quarterly-focused public market investors. Management can invest in research and development, infrastructure improvements, and strategic repositioning without worrying about the immediate impact on quarterly earnings reports.

Active Value Creation and Operational Excellence

Private equity firms take a hands-on approach to creating value in their portfolio companies. Unlike passive public market investing, private equity involves active management where firms work directly with companies to improve operations, strategy, and overall performance.

This active management approach includes:

  • Strengthening management teams and bringing in specialised expertise
  • Operational improvements through process optimisation and efficiency gains
  • Strategic direction and market positioning enhancements
  • Financial restructuring to optimise capital allocation
  • Governance changes to improve decision-making processes

Superior Alignment of Interests

The private equity ownership model creates superior alignment between owners, managers, and boards. The concentrated ownership structure of private equity-owned companies – with an engaged board – means key decisions can be voted on quickly without the need to convince a wide range of different shareholders with diverse interests.

Private equity boards tend to take a co-leadership role with the CEO on critical issues such as strategy and business performance. This heightened level of engagement provides a "license for action" that facilitates the freedom to make decisions and implement changes focused on creating value over the medium to long term.

Management Autonomy: The Hidden Competitive Advantage

Beyond long-term decision making, management autonomy represents one of the most profound advantages of private investment structures. This autonomy extends far beyond simply avoiding quarterly earnings calls – it fundamentally transforms how executives can lead, innovate, and build sustainable businesses.

Liberation from Investor Relations Burden: In public companies, management teams dedicate substantial time and resources to investor relations activities that don't directly create value. Private investment eliminates the quarterly earnings cycle, freeing management from quarterly earnings calls, guidance management, roadshow activities, and regulatory reporting complexity.

Strategic Decision-Making Independence: Private investment structures provide management with unprecedented strategic flexibility. Management can enter new markets or exit underperforming segments based on long-term strategic value rather than short-term earnings impacts. They can implement pricing strategies focused on long-term market positioning and pursue strategic partnerships that may require upfront investments but deliver long-term value.

Operational Innovation Freedom: Private ownership enables management-driven operational innovation without constant justification to external stakeholders. This includes implementing comprehensive process improvements, pursuing transformational technology initiatives, and restructuring organisations based on operational efficiency rather than external perceptions.

The Illiquidity Discount Rationalisation

One of the most sophisticated misconceptions in private asset investing involves using the volatility myth to justify overlooking the illiquidity discount that should theoretically apply to these investments. This represents a particularly dangerous form of circular reasoning that compounds the measurement problems we've explored.

The Circular Logic Structure

The argument typically follows this flawed logical sequence:

  1. Private assets appear less volatile due to infrequent pricing and smoothed returns
  2. Lower apparent volatility suggests lower risk and thus justifies lower required returns
  3. The "risk reduction benefit" offsets illiquidity constraints, eliminating the need for an illiquidity discount
  4. Therefore, private assets can command premium valuations despite their liquidity limitations

This reasoning is fundamentally circular because it uses an artifact of measurement methodology (smoothed volatility) to justify ignoring a real economic cost (illiquidity). The apparent risk reduction is largely illusory, yet it's used to rationalise accepting inadequate compensation for very real liquidity constraints.

The Double Distortion Effect

This creates a compounding distortion in investment decision-making. The smoothed volatility already understates true risk, and using this understated risk to justify ignoring illiquidity costs amplifies the measurement error exponentially. Instead of demanding higher returns to compensate for both true underlying risk AND illiquidity, investors accept lower returns based on artificially low apparent risk, creating a double discount to fair value.

The Liquid Alternatives Paradox

The recent surge in liquid alternatives represents a sophisticated attempt to engineer away the illiquidity discount, but it creates a fascinating paradox that may actually compound the measurement and valuation problems we've explored.

The Fundamental Liquidity Mismatch

Liquid alternatives have experienced explosive growth, now representing $540 billion in assets under management. These products attempt to provide "alternative exposures available in a liquid form," democratising access to strategies traditionally reserved for institutional investors.

However, this approach creates what experts call a fundamental liquidity mismatch. ETFs are designed for daily trading, while private assets often lack intraday liquidity. This mismatch creates several critical problems:

  • Valuation Challenges: Daily loan and NAV pricing can be inaccurate, leading to shares potentially trading at significant premiums or discounts
  • Forced Liquidation Risk: During redemption pressure, asset management firms might be forced to liquidate more-liquid holdings first, leaving a higher concentration of illiquid private assets in the fund
  • Create/Redeem Fee Volatility: The liquidity mismatch can result in higher create/redeem fees during market stress

Historical Evidence of Failure

The liquid alternatives industry's catastrophic failure rate provides compelling evidence of these structural problems. Since their launch after 2008, of the 453 liquid alternatives funds created, only 153 exist today – a mere 34% survival rate over 12.5 years.

The 2010s proved particularly brutal for liquid alternatives, with these funds averaging just 1.66% annual returns globally – the same figure as their median expense ratio. This means investors received a 50/50 split between returns and fees, effectively paying managers a dollar for every dollar earned.

Historical Lessons: When Liquidity Engineering Fails

History provides several compelling examples where the packaging of illiquid assets into liquid vehicles has created significant problems during periods of investor redemption pressure.

March 2020: The COVID-19 Stress Test

The March 2020 COVID-19 crash provided a real-world laboratory for testing liquid alternatives under extreme stress. Bond ETFs holding illiquid corporate bonds faced massive redemption pressure while their underlying assets became essentially untradeable. Research shows that during this period, ETFs holding more liquid bonds actually traded at larger discounts than those holding illiquid bonds – the opposite of what efficient markets would predict.

The 2008 Financial Crisis Precedent

The 2008 financial crisis offers the classic example of illiquid asset packaging failures. Major banks and insurers were forced to sell distressed mortgage debt at fire-sale prices when structured products that had appeared liquid suddenly became impossible to price or trade. The securitisation of illiquid mortgages into seemingly liquid instruments created systemic risk that materialised when external forces triggered widespread redemption demands.

The Current Private Equity Liquidation Crisis

The private equity industry is currently experiencing what many consider a significant liquidation crisis with multiple concerning indicators:

Crisis Indicators

Fundraising Collapse: Global private equity fundraising dropped 24% in 2024, representing the most significant decline since the 2008 financial crisis. This reduction in new capital creates pressure on existing funds to accelerate exits and return capital to investors.

Exit Backlog: Private equity firms face record backlogs of companies awaiting exits, with many portfolio companies held well beyond typical 3–5-year investment horizons. This backlog has created what industry experts call a "denominator effect" where LPs' PE allocations have grown beyond target levels due to unrealised investments.

Distribution Pressure: Distributions to paid-in capital has become the "most critical" performance metric for PE firms, reflecting LP demands for faster capital returns.

Institutional Investor Vulnerability

Elite university endowments represent particularly exposed institutions in the current crisis. Some major endowments hold as little as 21.6% in liquid assets (Princeton), creating potential liquidity mismatches when they face spending requirements or capital call obligations. Endowments have experienced negative cash flow balances in five of the last six years, meaning their private market investments are consuming more capital through calls than they're returning through distributions.

The Retail Democratisation Strategy: A Wealth Transfer in Disguise?

Perhaps the most concerning development in private assets is the aggressive push to bring retail investors into these markets precisely when institutional investors face overallocation pressures.

Evidence of Strategic Timing

There is substantial circumstantial evidence suggesting that the aggressive push to bring retail investors into private assets coincides with – and may be strategically designed to address – institutional investors' need to reduce their private market exposures.

The Institutional Overallocation Crisis: Public pension funds now have more than 30% allocations to private market classes, but the end of the low-interest rates era, the decline of private equity valuations, and the lack of exits has left most pension funds overallocated in private markets.

Explosive Retail Push Timeline: State Street research shows that 56% of institutional investors expect retail-style vehicles to account for at least half of private market flows by 2027, representing a dramatic shift from traditional institutional fundraising.

The Perfect Storm Scenario

The confluence of factors creates what appears to be a coordinated transfer mechanism:

  1. Institutional overallocation creates selling pressure precisely when exit markets are constrained
  2. Retail democratisation creates new demand from less sophisticated investors
  3. Liquid alternatives engineering makes illiquid assets appear more accessible
  4. Regulatory loosening reduces traditional retail investor protections
  5. Marketing emphasis on diversification benefits while downplaying liquidity risks

Implications for Sophisticated Investors

Understanding these dynamics has crucial implications for investment decision-making:

Due Diligence Requirements

Investors should demand unsmoothed return analyses when evaluating private asset allocations. Focus on fundamental risk factors like leverage, concentration, and economic exposure rather than reported volatility. Recognise that private assets may not provide the diversification benefits that smoothed statistics suggest.

Risk Assessment Framework

Separate risk and liquidity analysis – independently assess true underlying risk (using unsmoothed measures) and liquidity costs, rather than allowing apparent risk reduction to offset illiquidity requirements. Demand explicit illiquidity compensation regardless of apparent volatility characteristics, as liquidity constraints represent real opportunity costs independent of underlying asset risk.

Portfolio Construction Considerations

Maintain adequate liquid asset reserves to prevent forced selling during private market stress periods. Consider diversified vintage year exposure to reduce exposure to any single market cycle or liquidation pressure period. Participate actively in secondary markets to provide both liquidity options and opportunistic investment access during crisis periods.

Conclusion: Navigating the Private Assets Landscape

The private assets industry offers genuine benefits – long-term strategic focus, management autonomy, active value creation, and access to unique opportunities. However, these legitimate advantages have been obscured by sophisticated measurement problems and marketing narratives that systematically overstate the risk-adjusted benefits of private investing.

The confusion between risk and volatility, particularly regarding private assets, represents a fundamental challenge in modern portfolio management. The illusion of lower risk created by infrequent pricing has led to widespread misconceptions about the true risk-adjusted returns of private investments.

Sophisticated investors must look beyond surface-level volatility measures to understand the genuine risk characteristics of their portfolios. They must resist the circular reasoning that uses artificially smoothed returns to justify overlooking real illiquidity costs. And they must remain vigilant about the potential for wealth transfers from institutional to retail investors through sophisticated financial engineering.

The key is understanding that while private assets offer meaningful benefits, these benefits come with real costs – including genuine illiquidity constraints and potentially higher underlying volatility than traditional metrics suggest. Only by acknowledging these trade-offs honestly can investors make truly informed allocation decisions that serve their long-term financial objectives.

The private assets industry will continue to evolve, but the fundamental economic principles of risk, return, and liquidity remain constant. Investors who understand these principles – and can distinguish between genuine value creation and measurement artifacts – will be best positioned to capture the legitimate benefits of private investing while avoiding its increasingly sophisticated pitfalls.


Disclaimer 

The information provided on this post is of a general nature and does not take into account your personal financial situation, objectives, or needs. Before acting on any information, consider its appropriateness and seek advice from a licensed financial adviser. Dorset Wealth Management is authorised to provide financial services under Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) No. 558504. For more information, refer to our Financial Services Guide (FSG) or contact us directly.